Critically analyzing the societal impact of AI, including algorithmic bias and the importance of transparency.
If an AI system decides who gets a life-saving organ transplant based on data from a biased past, is it predicting the future or simply automating our old mistakes?
AI models are not inherently objective; they are mirrors of the data they consume. Algorithmic Bias typically enters the system through two primary channels: Historical Bias and Representation Bias. Historical bias occurs when the training data reflects existing societal prejudices (e.g., a hiring tool trained on 20 years of male-dominated resumes). Representation bias happens when certain groups are under-sampled, leading the model to perform poorly on those populations. For instance, if a facial recognition system is trained on a dataset that is Caucasian, its error rate for other ethnicities will be significantly higher because the model has not learned the necessary feature variances.
1. Imagine you remove 'Race' from a mortgage approval dataset to ensure fairness. 2. However, the dataset still includes 'Zip Code'. 3. Because of historical housing patterns, 'Zip Code' acts as a proxy variable for race. 4. The AI learns to discriminate based on the proxy, achieving the same biased result even without the explicit label.
Quick Check
Why does removing a protected attribute (like gender or race) from a dataset often fail to eliminate bias?
Answer
Because other variables in the dataset, known as proxy variables, can correlate strongly with the protected attribute, allowing the model to 'reconstruct' the bias.
In high-stakes fields like Healthcare or Criminal Justice, we face the 'Black Box' problem. Deep Learning models, particularly those with millions of parameters, are often uninterpretable. If a model denies a patient a specific treatment, doctors must know why. Without Explainable AI (XAI), we risk 'Automation Bias'—the human tendency to trust automated systems even when they are wrong. Ethically, we must balance Accuracy vs. Interpretability. A model with accuracy that cannot be explained may be less desirable in a courtroom than a accurate model that provides a clear reasoning path.
Quick Check
In the context of a medical AI, what is 'Automation Bias'?
Answer
The tendency for human clinicians to over-rely on or trust the AI's suggestions even when they contradict their own professional judgment or evidence.
1. To test if a loan-approval AI is truly fair, we use Counterfactuals. 2. Take a specific applicant who was rejected. 3. Change only their 'Gender' attribute in the data while keeping all other features constant. 4. If the AI's decision flips from 'Reject' to 'Approve' based solely on that change, the model has failed the test of counterfactual fairness.
Which type of bias occurs when a facial recognition system is trained primarily on one demographic group?
If a model's decision changes when you change a single demographic attribute (like gender) while keeping all other data the same, it lacks:
A 'Black Box' model is generally preferred in healthcare because its complexity always leads to safer outcomes.
Review Tomorrow
In 24 hours, try to explain the difference between 'Demographic Parity' and 'Counterfactual Fairness' to a peer.
Practice Activity
Find a public AI 'Model Card' (e.g., from Google or Hugging Face) and identify one limitation the developers disclosed regarding its training data.