Analyze situations where a transaction benefits society more than the individual buyer, such as vaccinations or schooling.
Why does the government pay for your school? If you get smarter, you make more money—so why shouldn't you pay for it all yourself? The answer lies in a hidden value that benefits people you haven't even met yet.
Quick Check
If a student gains 2,000 (MEB), what is the Marginal Social Benefit (MSB)?
Answer
The MSB is $12,000.
In a free market, consumers only consider their own MPB when deciding how much to buy. They will consume until their equals the price (), which represents the Marginal Social Cost (MSC). However, since they ignore the MEB, the market equilibrium quantity () is always lower than the socially optimal quantity (). This gap represents a Market Failure. Because we are missing out on units where the social benefit is higher than the cost, the economy suffers from Deadweight Loss (DWL). On a graph, this is the triangle pointing toward the socially optimal point, representing the 'lost' welfare of the units not produced.
1. Imagine a vaccine costs MSC = 2020, only 100 people feel the private benefit is worth the cost (). 3. However, if those 100 people get vaccinated, the 'herd immunity' benefit to others is worth another MSB20 + 10 = 30MSB (30) > MSC (20)$, society would be better off if more than 100 people were vaccinated.
Quick Check
In a graph of a positive externality, is the MSB curve located above or below the MPB curve?
Answer
The MSB curve is located above the MPB curve.
To fix under-consumption, governments use Subsidies. A subsidy is a payment to either the consumer or the producer that lowers the effective price. The goal is to 'internalize the externality.' If the government provides a subsidy exactly equal to the Marginal External Benefit (MEB), the consumer's perceived benefit shifts upward to align with the MSB. This encourages the market to reach . For example, public education is heavily subsidized because a literate, skilled workforce makes the entire country more productive and stable, far beyond the higher salary the individual student earns.
Suppose the market for solar panels is described by the following: 1. Demand (MPB): 2. Supply (MSC): 3. External Benefit (MEB): per unit.
Step 1: Find Market Equilibrium (): .
Step 2: Find Socially Optimal Quantity (): . .
Step 3: The optimal subsidy is the MEB, which is per unit. This shifts the market to produce 50 units instead of 40.
Which of the following is the best example of a positive externality?
At the free-market equilibrium for a good with a positive externality, which of the following is true?
To reach social efficiency, the government should set a subsidy equal to the Marginal External Benefit (MEB).
Review Tomorrow
In 24 hours, try to sketch a supply and demand graph showing MPB, MSB, and the area of Deadweight Loss for a positive externality.
Practice Activity
Look around your neighborhood. Identify one 'good' that is under-produced because of a positive externality (like a well-maintained historic home) and explain why a subsidy might help.