Navigation
Prepares students for college-level writing by teaching them how to combine multiple sources into one cohesive argument.
Imagine you are a judge presiding over a complex trial with five witnesses, a forensic report, and a video clip. If you simply repeat what each person said one by one, you haven't solved the case—to reach a verdict, you must weave the evidence together to reveal the 'big picture.'
Synthesis is not just a collection of summaries; it is the act of entering a conversation. Imagine a dinner party where three guests (Source A, Source B, and Source C) are debating a topic. Your job as the writer is not to follow each guest around and repeat what they said individually. Instead, you are the moderator. You identify where they agree, where they clash, and what new insight emerges from their interaction. This is the Synthesis Mindset. Your thesis is the 'verdict' or the 'conclusion' drawn from observing how these different voices interact. In a synthesis essay, your own voice must remain the loudest, using the sources as 'expert witnesses' to support your specific claims.
Quick Check
In the 'Dinner Party' metaphor, what is the writer's primary role?
Answer
The writer acts as a moderator who identifies connections and conflicts between sources to support a unique thesis.
The most common mistake in synthesis writing is the Laundry List approach: Paragraph 1 summarizes Source A, Paragraph 2 summarizes Source B, and so on. This is repetitive and fails to show logic. To write at an advanced level, you must use Thematic Organization. This means your body paragraphs are titled by ideas, not authors. For example, if your topic is 'The Ethics of AI,' your first body paragraph might be 'Privacy Concerns.' Within that paragraph, you would cite Source A and Source C together to show they both worry about data leaks, even if they disagree on the solution. This creates a 'horizontal' connection across your sources.
1. Weak (Source-Based) Outline: - Para 1: What Dr. Smith says about solar power. - Para 2: What the EPA report says about solar power. 2. Strong (Theme-Based) Outline: - Para 1: The high initial cost of solar implementation (Citing Smith and EPA). - Para 2: Long-term environmental benefits (Citing Smith and Green Peace Journal).
Quick Check
What is the main disadvantage of a 'Laundry List' essay structure?
Answer
It focuses on individual summaries rather than showing how sources relate to each other to support a central argument.
To organize complex information, use a Synthesis Matrix. This is a grid where rows are sources and columns are key themes. If Source 1 and Source 3 both have an 'X' in the 'Economic Impact' column, you have found a thematic connection for a body paragraph. When writing, use Signal Phrases to create a 'dialogue.' Instead of just dropping a quote, use phrases like: 'While Source A argues for , Source B counters with .' This shows the reader you aren't just reading the sources—you are analyzing the relationship between them. Always use the formula: Signal Phrase + Evidence + (Citation).
Step 1: Identify a common theme (e.g., Urbanization). Step 2: Find two sources with different perspectives. Step 3: Draft the sentence: 'Although Source A maintains that urbanization leads to economic growth, Source C cautions that this growth often comes at the expense of environmental sustainability (Source A; Source C).'
Think of synthesis as a logical equation. If Source A provides a premise and Source B provides a premise , your synthesis is the conclusion that can only be reached by combining them: 1. Source A: 'Remote work increases employee happiness.' 2. Source B: 'Happy employees are 20% more productive.' 3. Your Synthesis: 'By adopting remote work models, companies can leverage increased employee satisfaction to drive significant productivity gains (Source A; Source B).'
Which of the following best describes a 'thematic' body paragraph?
What is the purpose of a 'signal phrase' in a synthesis essay?
In a synthesis essay, your own thesis should be the 'verdict' reached after evaluating the evidence from all sources.
Review Tomorrow
In 24 hours, try to explain the 'Dinner Party' metaphor for synthesis to a friend or family member without looking at your notes.
Practice Activity
Take three different news articles about the same event. Create a simple 3x3 Synthesis Matrix to identify where the reporters agree and where their focus differs.