Navigation
Analyzes how states give up some sovereignty to join international organizations for mutual benefit.
Why would a powerful nation voluntarily give up its right to make its own laws or control its own currency? Imagine a world where your neighbors decide your taxes, but in exchange, you never have to worry about a break-in again.
Supranationalism occurs when three or more states () form an alliance to achieve shared goals. The defining characteristic is that member states must give up a portion of their sovereignty—their absolute authority over their own territory. This is a delicate balance: states trade individual power for collective strength. These alliances usually fall into three categories: Economic (wealth and trade), Military (defense), or Political (diplomacy and peace). In a world of globalized threats and markets, many states find that 'going it alone' is no longer a viable strategy.
Quick Check
What is the primary 'cost' a country pays to join a supranational organization?
Answer
The loss of a degree of national sovereignty (the power to make independent decisions).
The North Atlantic Treaty Organization (NATO) is the world's premier military alliance. Its core is 'collective defense,' meaning an attack on one member is treated as an attack on all. Conversely, the United Nations (UN) is a political organization focused on international peace and human rights. While the UN provides a forum for all 193 member states, its power is often concentrated in the Security Council. These organizations use centripetal forces to bind nations together through shared security interests and diplomatic norms.
1. Article 5 is the 'one-for-all' rule of NATO. 2. It has only been invoked once in history: after the September 11 attacks on the United States. 3. Because the US was attacked, all other NATO members (like the UK, Canada, and France) were obligated to assist in the response, demonstrating military supranationalism in action.
The European Union (EU) represents the most advanced form of supranationalism. It began as an economic agreement to prevent future wars but evolved into a massive political and economic entity. The EU created a Single Market, allowing for the 'four freedoms': the free movement of goods, services, capital, and people. Many members also adopted a common currency, the Euro (). However, this deep integration creates tension. When the EU passes a law, it often overrides the national laws of members like Germany or Italy, leading to political friction.
Consider a small business in France selling wine to Italy: 1. Benefit: Because both use the Euro (), there are zero currency exchange fees, saving roughly on every transaction. 2. Challenge: France cannot devalue its own currency to make its exports cheaper during a recession because it no longer controls the 'printing press'—the European Central Bank does. 3. Result: Economic stability is gained, but the 'monetary tool' of sovereignty is lost.
Quick Check
How does the 'Single Market' affect a citizen's ability to work in different countries?
Answer
It allows citizens of EU member states to live and work in any other member state without needing a special visa.
In Southeast Asia, ASEAN (Association of Southeast Asian Nations) focuses on economic growth and regional stability. Unlike the EU, ASEAN emphasizes 'non-interference' in the internal affairs of members. This highlights a major challenge of supranationalism: Devolution and Supranationalism are opposing forces. While supranationalism pulls states together (centripetal), forces like ethnic nationalism or economic inequality can pull them apart (centrifugal), sometimes leading to events like Brexit, where a state chooses to reclaim its full sovereignty.
The UK's departure from the EU (Brexit) illustrates the 'Sovereignty vs. Benefit' struggle: 1. The Argument: Pro-Brexit voters argued that the UK paid more into the EU budget than it received: . 2. The Counter-Argument: Economists argued the 'indirect' benefits of the Single Market (frictionless trade) outweighed the membership fee. 3. The Outcome: The UK chose to regain control over its borders and laws, but lost its duty-free access to its largest trading partners, showing that leaving a supranational body has significant economic 'friction' costs.
Which of the following is the best definition of supranationalism?
What type of supranational organization is NATO?
The 'Euro' is the official currency of every single country located in the continent of Europe.
Review Tomorrow
In 24 hours, try to list one economic, one military, and one political supranational organization and name one benefit of each.
Practice Activity
Research a recent news article about the 'Schengen Area' or 'NATO expansion' and identify whether the news represents a centripetal force (pulling together) or a centrifugal force (pushing apart).