Navigation
Explores the formation of the United States government and the practical application of Enlightenment principles in the Constitution.
Imagine you are designing a game where no single player is allowed to win too easily. How would you write the rules so that if one player gets too powerful, the others can automatically team up to stop them?
After winning independence from a monarchy, the Founders were terrified of concentrated power. Influenced by the Enlightenment philosopher Montesquieu, they designed a government with Separation of Powers. This means the government's responsibilities are divided into three distinct branches. The Legislative branch (Congress) makes the laws; the Executive branch (the President) enforces the laws; and the Judicial branch (the Courts) interprets the laws. By splitting these functions, no single person or group could control every aspect of the law, ensuring that the 'rules of the game' remained fair for everyone.
Quick Check
Which branch of government is responsible for interpreting whether a law follows the Constitution?
Answer
The Judicial branch.
Separating powers wasn't enough; the branches needed a way to restrain one another. This system is called Checks and Balances. It creates a constant 'tug-of-war' where each branch has the power to block or 'check' the others. For example, even if Congress passes a law, the President can veto (reject) it. However, Congress can then override that veto with a two-thirds majority vote. Later, the Supreme Court can declare that same law unconstitutional, effectively deleting it. This ensures that power is never static and always requires cooperation or broad agreement.
1. Congress passes a bill to tax all tea. 2. The President disagrees and issues a veto. 3. Congress votes again; if they reach a majority, the veto is overridden. 4. The Supreme Court reviews the law and decides if it violates the Constitution.
Quick Check
What is the term for the President's power to reject a law passed by Congress?
Answer
A veto.
One of the biggest challenges in 1787 was how to represent the people. Large states wanted representation based on population (the Virginia Plan), while small states wanted equal votes for every state (the New Jersey Plan). The solution was the Great Compromise, which created a bicameral (two-house) legislature. In the House of Representatives, seats are assigned by population, roughly following the ratio: . In the Senate, every state gets exactly 2 seats, regardless of size. This balanced the interests of both the 'people' and the 'states' as entities.
Imagine a country with two states: State A (1 million people) and State B (5 million people). 1. In a 'Senate-style' system, both get 2 votes. Total = 4. 2. In a 'House-style' system, if 1 seat = 1 million people, State A gets 1 seat and State B gets 5 seats. 3. The Great Compromise combines these, so State B has more power in the House, but equal power in the Senate.
Even with a balanced structure, many 'Anti-Federalists' feared the government would still trample on individual rights. To ensure the Constitution was ratified (approved), the Federalists promised to add a Bill of Rights. These first ten amendments act as a shield for the citizens. They protect fundamental liberties like freedom of speech, religion, and the press (1st Amendment), and the right to a fair trial. It shifted the focus from how the government functions to what the government cannot do to its people.
Consider a scenario where the police want to search a person's digital cloud storage without a warrant. 1. The 4th Amendment protects against 'unreasonable searches and seizures'. 2. The Judicial branch must decide: Does 'digital space' count as a 'house' or 'effect' under 18th-century definitions? 3. This demonstrates how the Bill of Rights is a 'living' protection applied to new technologies.
Which Enlightenment philosopher's ideas most directly influenced the 'Separation of Powers'?
In the Great Compromise, how is representation determined in the Senate?
The Bill of Rights was included in the original draft of the Constitution before the Anti-Federalists complained.
Review Tomorrow
In 24 hours, try to list the three branches of government and one way each branch can 'check' another without looking at your notes.
Practice Activity
Find a recent news article about a Supreme Court decision or a Presidential veto and identify which 'check' or 'balance' is being used.