Navigation
Examines the literary shift toward depicting everyday life and the unique cultural identities of different American regions.
Imagine a world where every book you read featured perfect heroes and magical endings—then suddenly, a war breaks out, and those stories feel like lies. How would you change your writing to tell the 'real' truth?
Before the mid-19th century, American literature was dominated by Romanticism, which emphasized the sublime, the individual imagination, and idealized heroes. However, the trauma of the Civil War acted as a catalyst for change. Writers felt that the old, 'flowery' style could no longer capture the grim reality of a fractured nation. Realism emerged as a literary movement that sought to portray life exactly as it was, without filter or exaggeration. Realists acted like social scientists, focusing on the middle class, everyday struggles, and the influence of environment on character. They traded 'what should be' for 'what is,' prioritizing character development over sensational plots.
Quick Check
If a Romantic writer describes a forest as a 'mystical cathedral of the soul,' how might a Realist writer describe it?
Answer
A Realist would likely describe the specific types of trees, the dampness of the soil, and perhaps the mosquitoes, focusing on the physical reality rather than spiritual meaning.
As the United States expanded, writers became obsessed with capturing the 'flavor' of specific areas. This sub-genre, known as Regionalism or Local Color, focused on the unique customs, dress, and landscapes of places like the Mississippi River or the California mining camps. A key tool for these writers was dialect—writing dialogue exactly as it sounded in a specific region. By using non-standard spelling and grammar to mimic speech, authors like Mark Twain gave a voice to people who had never been the 'heroes' of literature before. This wasn't just for decoration; it was a way to assert a unique American identity during a time of rapid national growth.
Observe the difference between standard English and Regionalist dialect: 1. Standard English: 'I did not know what to do, so I decided to leave.' 2. Regionalist Dialect (Twain style): 'I 'lowed I'd better git, 'fore the widow caught me lollygaggin'.'
Notice how the second sentence uses phonetic spelling ('lowed, 'fore) and regional slang (lollygaggin') to establish a specific cultural setting.
Quick Check
What is the primary purpose of using 'Local Color' in a story?
Answer
To capture the specific atmosphere, customs, and speech patterns of a particular geographical region to make the setting feel authentic.
The shift toward Realism wasn't just an artistic choice; it was driven by Industrialization and Urbanization. As people moved from farms to crowded cities, writers began to explore themes of class conflict, poverty, and the loss of innocence. This eventually led to Naturalism, an extreme form of Realism. Naturalists believed that humans were subject to forces beyond their control, such as heredity and environment. If we represent the 'power' of a character's choice as and the 'force' of their environment as , a Naturalist might argue that in almost every scenario. This 'scientific' approach stripped away the idea of the 'self-made man' and replaced it with a more complex, often darker, view of human existence.
Consider a story about a coal miner in the 1880s. 1. Romantic approach: The miner finds a hidden gem and escapes his life through sheer willpower. 2. Realist/Naturalist approach: The miner develops a cough (black lung), his wages are cut by the company, and his 'destiny' is determined by the geological and economic conditions of the town.
In the Realist version, the 'Place' (the mine) is effectively a character that dictates the plot.
Which historical event most directly contributed to the rise of Realism in America?
If an author writes 'He hadn't no business being there,' to mimic a specific character's speech, they are using:
Realist writers preferred sensational, action-packed plots over deep character development.
Review Tomorrow
In 24 hours, try to explain the difference between 'Local Color' and 'Romanticism' to a friend without looking at your notes.
Practice Activity
Find a news article about a local event. Rewrite the first paragraph twice: once as a 'Romantic' (focusing on grand emotions) and once as a 'Realist' (focusing on objective, gritty details).