Navigation
Learn to compare and contrast the information gained from reading a text with the information from a visual representation.
Have you ever seen a movie after reading the book and thought, 'That character looks nothing like I imagined!'? Why does our brain build different worlds than the ones we see on screen?
When we read, authors use figurative language and imagery to paint a picture in our minds. For example, a writer might use a simile like 'his heart was as heavy as a lead weight' to describe sadness. This is called a 'mental movie.' However, when an artist creates a visual representation—like an illustration or a movie scene—they have to make specific choices. They choose the exact color of the character's hair, the brightness of the sun, and the size of the room. While the text gives us the 'ingredients,' the visual gives us the 'finished meal.' Comparing the two helps us see what the artist kept the same and what they changed based on their own imagination.
Let's look at how a description translates to an image: 1. The Text: 'The dragon had scales like polished emeralds and eyes that glowed like twin embers in a campfire.' 2. The Visual: A drawing of a bright green, shiny dragon with glowing orange eyes. 3. The Comparison: The color (green/emerald) is a similarity. The 'glow' is also a similarity. However, the text doesn't say how many legs the dragon has, but the artist had to choose to draw four.
Quick Check
What is the term for language that helps a reader 'see' a story in their mind?
Answer
Imagery
Text and visuals have different 'superpowers.' Text is excellent at showing internal traits, such as a character's secret thoughts or hidden feelings. A book can tell you exactly what someone is thinking using person or person narration. Visuals, on the other hand, excel at showing external traits. An image can show us the texture of a character's clothing, the exact layout of a messy bedroom, or the physical distance between two people. When we compare them, we look for how a visual artist uses 'body language' or 'color' to show a feeling that the book described in words.
1. The Text: 'Sarah felt a mountain of anxiety growing inside her as she walked toward the stage.' 2. The Visual: A picture of Sarah standing near a stage. She is biting her fingernails, her shoulders are hunched, and the background is a cold, dark blue. 3. The Analysis: The text tells us she is anxious. The visual shows us through her posture and the color of the room.
Quick Check
Which medium is usually better at explaining a character's secret thoughts?
Answer
Text (or written descriptions)
Sometimes, a visual can provide more information than a text, and sometimes it's the other way around. This is the Detail Duel. If a story says 'the forest was spooky,' that is a low-detail description. A visual of that forest might show twisted oak trees, a thick gray mist, and a hidden owl watching from a branch—providing more detail. However, if the text explains the history of the forest and why it was cursed 100 years ago, the text provides more detail than a single image ever could. To evaluate them, ask: 'What do I know now that I didn't know before?'
Imagine comparing a 5-page chapter about a magical compass to one single photograph of it. 1. Text Details: The compass was made by a blacksmith in 1802 (), it smells like ozone, and it vibrates when near gold. 2. Visual Details: The compass is circular, made of rusted brass, has a cracked glass face, and a leather strap. 3. The Evaluation: The text wins on history and senses (smell/vibration). The visual wins on physical condition (rust/cracks).
If a book says a character is 'as fast as lightning' and a movie shows them running with sparks behind them, what is this an example of?
Which of these is a 'visual-only' detail that a text might skip?
A visual representation can show a character's thoughts more clearly than a text description can.
Review Tomorrow
Tomorrow, try to remember the 'Detail Duel.' Can you think of one thing a book tells you that a picture cannot?
Practice Activity
Pick a paragraph from your favorite book. Draw a picture of it, then list three things you had to 'add' to the picture that weren't in the words.