Navigation
Investigating why physical processes give rise to subjective inner experiences and the limits of objective science.
If you and a friend both look at a ripe strawberry and call it 'red,' how can you be certain that your internal experience of 'redness' isn't exactly what they experience as 'blue'?
In the philosophy of mind, qualia (singular: quale) are the subjective, first-person 'raw feels' of our experiences. Think of the specific bitterness of dark chocolate, the sharp sting of a papercut, or the vibrant hue of a sunset. While science can measure the wavelength of light ( nm for red) or the chemical composition of cocoa, it struggles to capture the actual phenomenal character—the 'what-it-is-likeness'—of the experience itself. Qualia are private; you cannot directly share your internal 'redness' with anyone else, leading philosophers to wonder if our inner worlds are truly identical.
Consider two people, Alice and Bob, who have perfectly functioning eyes but 'inverted' internal experiences. 1. Alice sees a strawberry and experiences 'Redness.' 2. Bob sees the same strawberry, but his brain produces the internal sensation Alice would call 'Green.' 3. Because Bob was taught since birth that this sensation is called 'Red,' he behaves exactly like Alice. 4. Result: No physical test can prove their internal worlds are different, demonstrating that qualia are distinct from behavior.
Quick Check
Which of the following is an example of a 'quale'?
Answer
The specific, subjective smell of a rainy sidewalk (petrichor).
Philosopher David Chalmers famously divided the study of consciousness into two categories. The 'Easy Problems' aren't actually simple, but they are tractable via standard neuroscience. They involve explaining how the brain integrates information, categorizes stimuli, or controls behavior. We can imagine a blueprint where Neuron triggers Muscle . However, the 'Hard Problem' asks: Why does all this physical processing give rise to an inner life at all? Why aren't we just 'biological robots' (or philosophical zombies) that process data without any 'glow' of internal experience?
1. A digital camera captures light, converts it to binary data (s and s), and stores it. This is an 'Easy Problem' (functional processing). 2. A human eye captures light, converts it to neural impulses, and the person feels the warmth and brightness of the light. 3. The 'Hard Problem' is explaining the gap between the neural impulse (the s and s) and the 'feeling' of warmth.
Quick Check
According to Chalmers, why is explaining the ability to react to a loud noise an 'easy problem'?
Answer
Because it can be explained by mapping the physical pathways of sound waves to neural triggers and muscle movements.
Frank Jackson proposed a thought experiment to challenge physicalism (the view that everything is physical). Imagine Mary, a brilliant scientist who lives her entire life in a black-and-white room. She learns every physical fact about color: the physics of light, the biology of the retina, and the neural firing patterns. One day, she steps outside and sees a red apple for the first time. Jackson argues that Mary learns something new: she learns what it is like to see red. If she knew all the physical facts but still learned something new, then physical facts are not the only facts that exist.
This thought experiment tests the logical possibility of physicalism: 1. Imagine a creature that is physically identical to you down to the last atom (). 2. This 'zombie' behaves exactly like you, laughs at jokes, and winces at pain. 3. However, it has zero internal experience; it is 'dark' inside. 4. If such a being is even conceivable, it suggests that consciousness is something 'extra' added to the physical world, not just a byproduct of it.
What does the term 'Qualia' specifically refer to?
In the 'Mary's Room' experiment, what is the 'Knowledge Argument' trying to prove?
David Chalmers' 'Easy Problems' are called easy because they require very little scientific research to solve.
Review Tomorrow
In 24 hours, try to explain the difference between a 'physical fact' about pain (nerves firing) and the 'quale' of pain to a friend.
Practice Activity
Keep a 'Qualia Journal' for 10 minutes: try to describe the 'feel' of three things (e.g., the taste of water, the sound of traffic) without using any technical or scientific terms.