Navigation
Introduction to skepticism and why questioning everything can lead to deeper understanding.
What if everything you see right now—this screen, your hands, the room around you—is actually a hyper-realistic dream or a computer simulation? How could you prove, with 100% certainty, that you aren't just a 'brain in a vat' being fed electrical signals?
In everyday life, being 'skeptical' usually means you don't believe someone. In philosophy, Skepticism is much more powerful. It is the practice of questioning the certainty of our knowledge. Instead of just accepting things as true, a skeptic asks: 'How do I know this for sure?' This isn't about being negative; it’s about building a foundation of knowledge that cannot be shaken. Think of it like a filter for your mind—it lets the truth pass through while catching errors, biases, and illusions. By doubting what is weak, we eventually find what is strong.
Quick Check
According to the text, what is the primary goal of philosophical skepticism?
Answer
To question the certainty of knowledge in order to find truths that cannot be shaken.
In the 1600s, philosopher Rene Descartes wanted to find a truth that was impossible to doubt. He used an analogy: Imagine you have a basket of apples, but you suspect some are rotten. If you leave the rotten ones inside, they will spoil the rest. To save your snack, you must dump out every apple, inspect them one by one, and only put the perfectly healthy ones back. Descartes decided to 'dump out' all his beliefs—even his belief in the physical world—to see if any 'perfect' truths remained.
Descartes realized our senses often trick us. 1. Think of a straight straw in a glass of water; it looks bent (), but it is actually straight. 2. Think of a giant tower in the distance that looks like a tiny dot. 3. Because our senses can be fooled once, a skeptic argues they cannot be trusted as a source of absolute certainty.
Descartes went even further. He imagined an Evil Demon whose only job was to trick his mind into thinking the world existed when it didn't. But then, he hit a breakthrough. Even if a demon was tricking him, something had to exist to be tricked! He realized that the very act of doubting proved he was thinking. And if he was thinking, he must exist. He expressed this in the famous Latin phrase: Cogito, ergo sum, or 'I think, therefore I am.' This was his one 'perfect apple'—the foundation of all his knowledge.
Let represent 'I exist' and represent 'I am thinking.' 1. If you try to doubt that you exist, you are performing a thought (). 2. You cannot have a thought () without a thinker (). 3. Therefore, the statement 'I do not exist' is a logical contradiction. As long as you are conscious of the question, you have proof of your own existence.
Quick Check
Why did Descartes believe that 'I think, therefore I am' was a truth that couldn't be doubted?
Answer
Because even the act of doubting requires a thinker to exist; you cannot doubt your own existence without existing to do the doubting.
It is important to distinguish between Skepticism and Denialism. A skeptic says, 'I will believe this once I see sufficient evidence.' A denialist says, 'I refuse to believe this regardless of the evidence.' Healthy skepticism is the engine of science. It leads us to test theories, check for bias, and update our views when new data appears. Without doubt, we would still believe the Earth is the center of the universe! Skepticism isn't about knowing nothing; it's about being brave enough to admit what we don't know yet.
Imagine a new 'miracle' energy drink claims to increase IQ by . 1. A denialist says: 'That's impossible, science is a lie.' 2. A gullible person says: 'Wow, I'll buy ten cases!' 3. A skeptic says: 'What was the sample size ()? Was there a control group? Was the study peer-reviewed?' They withhold judgment until the evidence is verified.
What does the 'Apple Basket' analogy represent in Descartes' philosophy?
Which of the following would a 'Healthy Skeptic' most likely do?
Descartes believed that because our senses can trick us (like an optical illusion), they cannot provide us with absolute certainty.
Review Tomorrow
In 24 hours, try to explain the 'Evil Demon' thought experiment to a friend and why it led Descartes to the 'Cogito'.
Practice Activity
Pick one 'fact' you heard today (in the news or from a friend). Apply the skeptic's filter: What evidence supports it? Could there be another explanation? How do you know it's true?