Navigation
A look at why some philosophers believe a strong central authority is necessary to prevent chaos.
Imagine a world with no laws, no police, and no government. If someone took your belongings by force, there would be no one to call for help. In this world, would you be truly free, or would you be living in a constant state of fear?
Thomas Hobbes, writing during the chaos of the English Civil War, asked a terrifying question: What is the natural human condition? He called this the State of Nature. In this hypothetical world, there are no laws or authorities. Hobbes argued that because humans are naturally selfish and competitive, life without a government would be a 'war of all against all.' Without a common power to keep everyone in awe, there is no industry, no culture, and no society. He famously described life in this state as 'solitary, poor, nasty, brutish, and short.'
Quick Check
According to Hobbes, what is the primary motivation for humans to leave the 'State of Nature'?
Answer
The fear of violent death and the desire for a peaceful, secure life.
To escape the horror of the State of Nature, Hobbes proposed the Social Contract. This is an agreement where individuals collectively give up their right to do whatever they want in exchange for protection. Imagine a group of people standing in a circle, each holding a sword. The Social Contract is the moment they all agree to drop their swords simultaneously and hand them to one person in the center. By surrendering their individual power, they create a collective peace. This 'contract' isn't a physical document, but a logical foundation for why we obey laws today.
1. Imagine 20 people are stranded on an island with limited coconuts. 2. In the State of Nature, the strongest person might take all the coconuts by force. 3. The group realizes that constant fighting means no one sleeps safely. 4. They agree to a Social Contract: they will all stop fighting and appoint one person to distribute the coconuts fairly. 5. The 'cost' is that no one can take extra coconuts whenever they want anymore; the 'benefit' is that no one gets hit with a rock while they sleep.
Hobbes argued that for the Social Contract to work, the person or group in charge must have absolute power. He called this ruler the Leviathan, named after a massive sea monster from the Bible. Hobbes believed that if the ruler's power was divided or limited, people would find ways to disagree and slide back into civil war. The Sovereign must be the final judge of all laws and even all truths. In Hobbes' view, even a harsh or 'bad' ruler is better than the chaos of having no ruler at all. This is a purely functional view of justice: order is the highest good.
Quick Check
Why did Hobbes insist that the Sovereign's power must be absolute rather than shared?
Answer
He believed shared power leads to disagreement, which leads to conflict, eventually returning society to the chaos of the State of Nature.
We can think of Hobbes' theory as a balance scale. On one side is Security () and on the other is Liberty (). Hobbes argues that to maximize , we must minimize .
1. In the State of Nature: . 2. In the Leviathan's State: . 3. Hobbes' logic: If , then the risk of becoming is too high. Therefore, we must accept to ensure .
Consider modern surveillance. Some argue that to prevent terrorism (the modern 'State of Nature'), the government should have the power to monitor all digital communications.
1. The Hobbesian Argument: Total surveillance (Absolute Authority) prevents chaos and keeps us safe. 2. The Risk: If the 'Leviathan' (the government) becomes corrupt, the citizens have no power to stop it because they gave up their rights for safety. 3. The Question: Is the 'peace' of a prison better than the 'danger' of a free society?
Which phrase did Hobbes use to describe life in the State of Nature?
In the Social Contract, what is the 'currency' that people trade for security?
Hobbes believed that a bad ruler was still better than no ruler at all.
Review Tomorrow
Tomorrow morning, try to explain the 'State of Nature' to a friend or family member using the 'Desert Island' analogy without looking at your notes.
Practice Activity
Look up a news story about a country experiencing a 'failed state' or civil war. How does this real-world situation reflect Hobbes' fears about the State of Nature?