Navigation
Compares major therapeutic modalities including CBT, Psychodynamic, and Humanistic therapies.
Why do two people experience the exact same event—like a job loss—and react in completely opposite ways? The answer isn't in what happened, but in the hidden psychological architecture of their minds.
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) is a structured, goal-oriented approach that focuses on the relationship between thoughts, feelings, and behaviors. It operates on the principle that our interpretations of events, rather than the events themselves, cause distress. The cornerstone of this approach is the ABC Model developed by Albert Ellis. In this framework, an Activating Event () does not directly cause emotional Consequences (). Instead, our Beliefs () about the event act as the intermediary. By identifying and challenging irrational beliefs, clients can change their emotional outcomes. This process is known as cognitive restructuring.
Consider a student who receives a 'C' on a paper. 1. **Activating Event ():** Receiving the grade. 2. **Belief ():** 'I am a failure and will never get into college.' 3. **Consequence ():** Feelings of worthlessness and the behavior of giving up on the next assignment. 4. Intervention: The therapist helps the student replace with a rational belief: 'This was one difficult paper; I can improve with feedback.' This leads to a more adaptive .
Quick Check
In the ABC model, which component is the primary target for change in therapy?
Answer
The Beliefs (B), as they determine the emotional and behavioral consequences.
Psychodynamic therapy, rooted in Freudian theory, seeks to bring unconscious conflicts into conscious awareness. It assumes that current problems stem from childhood experiences and repressed impulses. The goal is insight: understanding the 'why' behind behavior. In contrast, Humanistic therapy (specifically Carl Rogers' Client-Centered Therapy) focuses on the 'here and now.' It rejects the idea of the therapist as an authority figure. Instead, it emphasizes Unconditional Positive Regard, Empathy, and Genuineness. The goal is self-actualization, helping the client close the gap between their ideal self and actual self.
1. Psychodynamic Scenario: A client becomes irrationally angry at their therapist for being two minutes late. The therapist identifies this as transference, where the client is redirecting feelings toward a parent onto the therapist. 2. Humanistic Scenario: The same client expresses frustration. The therapist uses active listening and reflection: 'It sounds like you feel disrespected when people aren't on time.' The therapist provides a non-judgmental space to foster the client's own growth.
Quick Check
Which therapy type is most likely to focus on childhood memories and the unconscious mind?
Answer
Psychodynamic therapy.
In clinical psychology, Evidence-Based Practice (EBP) involves integrating the best available research with clinical expertise and patient characteristics. Not all therapies are equally effective for all conditions. For example, CBT is the 'gold standard' for Major Depressive Disorder and Generalized Anxiety Disorder. However, for Borderline Personality Disorder (BPD), a specialized form of CBT called Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT) is preferred. Exposure Therapy, a behavioral technique, is the primary treatment for Phobias and PTSD. Selecting the right modality is a matter of matching the treatment's mechanism to the disorder's pathology.
Imagine a patient presenting with both chronic depression and a history of childhood trauma. 1. A clinician might use a multimodal approach. 2. They may start with CBT to manage immediate depressive symptoms ( logic). 3. Later, they may incorporate Psychodynamic elements to explore how the childhood trauma created the core schemas (deep-seated beliefs) that fuel the depression. 4. This demonstrates how EBP is often an integration of techniques rather than a rigid adherence to one school of thought.
Which concept describes a Humanistic therapist's attitude of total acceptance toward a client?
If a therapist is helping a patient identify 'automatic thoughts' that lead to anxiety, they are likely practicing:
Psychodynamic therapy is primarily concerned with the 'here and now' rather than childhood history.
Review Tomorrow
In 24 hours, try to explain the ABC model to a friend using a real-life example of a minor frustration you experienced today.
Practice Activity
Create a Venn diagram comparing Psychodynamic and Humanistic therapies. What is one thing they have in common despite their different focuses?